The importance of utility and security tokens in ICOs staying relevant today has to be the priority for entrepreneurs, corporations as big investors. These tokens are different from each other, and have separate legal consequences. This article will distinguish these two variants, including their purpose and the corresponding legal environment.
For anyone looking at the best crypto to invest in today, check out Leading Cryptocurrency to Invest Today.
What Are ICO Tokens?
ICO tokens are digital assets issued by companies during an Initial Coin Offering, a fundraising mechanism used by blockchain-based projects. These tokens can be categorized into two main types: Security tokens and Utility tokens. Comprehending these categories can help investors make informed decisions and navigate the regulatory environment.
Utility Tokens: Access and Functionality
Utility tokens are designed to provide access to a company’s product or service. Their main use is not as investments but rather the access-key mechanisms of a given ecosystem.
Key Characteristics of Utility Tokens
- Access to Services: Utility tokens invite the possessors to gain access to an explicit asset or a service. For example, Filecoin tokens can be used to access decentralized storage on the Filecoin network.
- Non-Investment Nature: These tokens are not promoted as investment opportunities. The worth of them is by what they can do for you, not the monetary return on it.
- Regulatory Exemption: Utility tokens typically are not considered investment contracts and, thus, as non-securities provisions. This enables companies to issue them without having to satisfy robust securities laws.
Examples and Use Cases
Utility tokens are commonly used in various applications, such as:
- Gaming: Provides tokens that help players buy in-game items or unlock certain functions.
- Decentralized Exchanges: Tokens pay for fees and can participate in the governance.
- Social Media: Tokens for premium content and tipping mechanisms
One utility token that has been successful is the Basic Attention Token (BAT), which can be used within the Brave browser to pay users for viewing advertisements and also in order allow content creators.
For more details on how to create and store a cryptocurrency wallet, see How to Create a Crypto Wallet.
Security Tokens: Investment and Ownership
A security token usually represents a portion of ownership in the company or an asset. These are structured around securities regulation that also possess ownership rights or profits.
Key Characteristics of Security Tokens
- Investment Contracts: The goal of issuing security tokens is to profit from other people’s labor. They are therefore comparable to conventional securities like stocks and bonds.
- Regulatory Compliance: These types of tokens must be able to follow the securities laws that involve lots of reporting, disclosure requirements and investor protections.
- Ownership and Profit Sharing: Security tokens can be backed with company equity, giving them a claim in the success of their issuer which often includes receiving dividends.
Examples and Use Cases
Security tokens are for a set of financial applications including:
- Real Estate: Tokens that basically hold a portion of ownership in the real estate properties.
- Equity Crowdfunding: Tokens that offer shares in a startup, enabling new ways to raise capital.
- Investment Funds: Tokens that represent ownership in a fund and yield profit returns to an investor based on the account of assets within a fund.
An example that comes to mind is Polymath, which operates in the security token space and provides a platform for companies looking to issue compliant security tokens.
Legal Implications and the Howey Test
Legal differentiation between utility and security tokens is most commonly assessed via the Howey Test, defined by the U.S. Supreme Court. A transaction satisfies the following requirements in order to be classified as a security, per the Howey Test:
- Investment of Money: There is an investment of money.
- Common Enterprise: The investment is in a common enterprise.
- Expectation of Profits: There is an expectation of profits.
- Efforts of Others: The profits are derived from the efforts of others.
If a token satisfies these conditions, then the token is considered as security and would have to comply with existing securities regulations.
Risks and Considerations
The success of either utility or security tokens in themselves when it comes to investing in ICOs is not easy. While utility tokens can avoid getting swallowed up in a wave of regulations, they remain largely tied to the fate of their projects. If the project is unsuccessful, it can make that token useless and worthless.
On the flip side, security tokens are more compliant in practice but also riddled with regulatory mess logistics and that whole investing being risky thing.
Conclusion
This is where the differences between utility and security tokens should be well understood by any investor who wishes to join an ICO. Utility tokens can provide access or section functionality and thereby be less tightly regulated, but they are often reliant upon a project’s success. They allow investment opportunities with huge rights of ownership but have extremely strict legal requirements. Both are important in a changing blockchain and cryptocurrency ecosystem, each carrying its own advantages and disadvantages.
